Tuition fees
'Forgive my sense of deja vu': students on Theresa May's tuition fees review
Students past and present respond to May’s review into higher education funding
Guardian readers and
Matthew Holmes
Mon 19 Feb 2018 17.20 GMT
Last modified on Mon 19 Feb 2018 17.21 GMT
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share via Email
View more sharing options
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Pinterest
Share on Google+
Share on WhatsApp
Share on Messenger
Close
George, 21, politics and sociology student at the University of Bristol
I』m sceptical at best about the review. When the fees were increased to £9,000 we were all told only a handful of institutions would actually be offering courses at that price. What happened? Nearly every institution is offering courses at the maximum £9,250.
Read more
From what I can tell the prime minister intends to let some universities increase prices once the current 「freeze」 on fees is lifted, while others will have to reduce them according to whichever metric the government decides upon. Who gets to decide which courses are worth more than others? Forgive my sense of deja vu.
I don』t think my course is worth the money at all. We』ve been under the impression in our department that social science fees cross-subsidise the more expensive courses such as medicine and engineering. There was even a protest about this at our university. However, I found out yesterday that course fees for these subjects are 「topped-up」 by the government directly. Which makes me wonder, if my £9,000 a year is not fully paying for my course, nor the courses of more expensive subjects … then where’s my money going?
I went to a state school where most students either don』t go to university or go to 「newer」 universities with generally lower entry requirements. Few students from my cohort made it into Russell Group universities. A £3,500 maintenance loan that barely covered my extortionate rent in university-managed halls resulted in me spending my last few months commuting between Swindon and Bristol. The discrepancies between different students』 financial situations can really become apparent at university.
Jess, 21, engineering student at Durham University
The idea of reducing fees for humanities does not add up. We have a shortage in skills in Stem [science, technology, engineering and maths] subjects and nursing, midwifery etc, so in my view, if fees are to be reduced then doing so in those areas will be what encourages new students.
From my experience and that of my friends, the barrier is not the fees, it is the living costs. Next year Durham will be charging over £8,000 for most first-year accommodation, which most people I know would have struggled to afford. And given the way the loans are repaid, the size of the final loan for most graduates is not an issue; the government would be better looking into helping students afford the cost of living if it truly wants to help low income students access higher education.
Personally I feel my course is value for money due to the contact hours (25-30 a week in the first three years) and the resources available. However, the value of living accommodation here is very poor. The accommodation is low quality, small and expensive, with even shared rooms costing only £250 less per term than single. Those with middle incomes seem to fare worst of all. My friends with parents on very low incomes still received significant grants so could afford university, and those with wealthy parents similarly had no issues as their parents can contribute. Those in the middle whose parents earn over the threshold for maximum loans but who cannot afford to give their children thousands of pounds a year seem to have the most difficulty affording things.
John Robinson, 25, graduated with a BSc in biomedical science from Sheffield Hallam University in 2013
I can see the need for a review, though I think it’s perhaps focused in the wrong place if student decision-making is in mind. I』m not against the idea of a fund, as laid out by Justine Greening (as someone who likely won』t ever pay my loan off, perhaps that’s easy for me to say) but I don』t think it’s likely to change a prospective student’s mind.
My greatest concern was, and would be today, how I lived on the maintenance loan of £3,500 (which barely covered my rent) compared with others who received double that, predominantly in grants. I burned through some savings and worked twice a week at a fast-food restaurant, but even with that, and £25 a week off my parents, I needed to work full-time during summer holidays. Most accommodation options were still outside my price range, unless I wanted to work several days a week alongside my studies.
I also want to know whether this prospective system flattens maintenance loans, or even potentially reduces them? I didn』t move into the same field as my degree, but the lessons learned were probably worth the £3,200 a year I paid for them. I don』t know if I would agree to £9,000, though. The review is welcome, but that doesn』t mean I』m holding my breath for a better system.
Topics
Tuition fees
Higher education
Students
Theresa May
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share via Email
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Pinterest
Share on Google+
Share on WhatsApp
Share on Messenger
Reuse this content
本文來源:https://www.theguardian.com/education/2018/feb/19/forgive-my-sense-of-deja-vu-students-on-theresa-mays-tuition-fees-review
Bonnie | ||
89 |
Bonnie2018-02-20 10:46:38
調整公共服務資源空間佈局,多所北京高校均有實質性進展。記者1月25日自北京市人代會獲悉,2018年,北京城市學院將啟動順義校區三期工程,北京信息科技大學昌平新校區建設也將全面開工。而在去年底,北京...
Bonnie2018-02-20 10:46:38
【科學講堂】極低溫致超流體超導體現象
Bonnie2018-02-20 10:46:38
2018年1月29日上午,縣教研室程欣印主任、王自爭副主任及教育學會黨支部書記王錦濤一行3人冒着嚴寒,來到古坦學校指導期末考試工作。 程新祥校長匯報了學校期末考試的安排工作,由於前一天下了雪,程村、...
Bonnie2018-02-20 10:46:38
編者按:當前,各類機構組織的中小學競賽和培訓異常火爆。缺乏規範的中小學競賽市場,增加了參賽學生家長的經濟負擔,衝擊了中小學正常的教育秩序,對減輕學生過重負擔、促進健康成長十分不利。針對這一問題,人民論...